The Cambridge Companion to Brentano, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, ____ (), Immanent realism: an introduction to Brentano. The word itself, which is of medieval Scholastic origin, was rehabilitated by the philosopher Franz Brentano towards the end of the nineteenth. Intencionalidad y verdad en el juicio: Una propuesta de Brentano (Publicaciones de la Facultad de Filosofía y Letras de la Universidad de Navarra. Colección.
|Published (Last):||27 September 2010|
|PDF File Size:||20.96 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||11.54 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Suppose that it is constitutive of the nature of intentionality that one could not exemplify such mental states as loving, hating, desiring, believing, judging, perceiving, hoping, and so on, unless there was something to be loved, hated, desired, believed, judged, perceived, hoped, and so on.
The concept of intentionality has played a central role both in the tradition of analytic philosophy and in the phenomenological tradition. History of Western Philosophy. If Cleopatra loves Caesar, then presumably there is some concrete particular in space and time whom Cleopatra loves. Intenclonalidad Tye’s view, for example, pains are mental representations of bodily parts and the phenomenal experience of a pain is the nonconceptual content of the bodily representation.
First, if a linguistic context is extensional, two coreferential terms can be substituted one for the other salva veritate as illustrated by 16 and It is a natural law that all P s are R.
La doctrina de la intencionalidad en Franz Brentano
Frege offered a very influential solution brehtano both puzzles. For a recent novel account of the distinction between true and false thoughts about non-existent objects, cf. This issue has nothing especially to do with ontological dualism: But unless the device had some function, it could simply not misfunction. It is the function of an order to represent a non-actual possible or impossible state of affairs.
This strategy is related to the assumption that intentional relations whose relata are concrete particulars should have primacy over intentional relations whose brentaho are not see section 6. According to descriptivism, we can only think about objects by thinking about the properties which they instantiate.
On the one hand, by making intensionality the criterion of intentionality, one in effect espouses a general linguistic view of intentionality. Chisholm’s criterion of intensionality is threefold.
Brentano y los problemas de intencionalidad | Revista Filosofía UIS
How can one reconcile the local and the relational characters of propositional attitudes? On the other hand, it would show that some of the normativity of mental states is already exhibited by biological functions see Neander, As one reads these lines, numerous questions arise: The Nature of ConsciousnessCambridge, Mass.: Les Etudes Philosophiques 18 4: Fred Dretske has argued that the intentionality of many of an individual’s beliefs and desires results from an ontogenetic non-intentional process of selective learning.
The president of France elected in might have a been a Socialist. A problem with this strategy is that intencilnalidad is not clear just how narrow content is to be individuated. Crowe – – Philosophical Studies But intencionalirad are constituents of the contents of the former. The entry falls into eleven sections: On the Fregean view, what is essential to the thought or proposition expressed by an utterance of a sentence containing a singular term is its sensenot its reference.
If so, then the fact that disks exemplify a historical extrinsic property does play a role in the causal explanation of the structure of the machine’s behavior. Sign in Create an account.
The relational nature of singular thoughts Many non-intentional relations hold of concrete particulars in space and time. The entry falls into eleven sections:. What is it to have such mental states?
Conversely, if it is about Pegasus, then Pegasus must exist. Arguably, the cognitive enhancement argument applies not only to non-bodily tools but to bodily tools e. To show that one can do so, however, is no easy task. Millikan’s claim, however, is not that having a function is sufficient for aboutness, but that it is necessary. Or did he mean both?
So, for example, the truth of 21 does not entail the truth of 22 even though everything that happens to exemplify property Q happens to exemplify property R: According to Kripkeunlike proper names, whose rigidity is de juredefinite descriptions expressing essential properties of an object are rigid de facto. Would you like to tell us about a lower price? It is brntano natural law that all P s are Q.
So, for example, the truth of 21 does not entail the truth of 22 even though everything that happens to exemplify property Q happens to exemplify property R:.
Whereas Inga, a healthy adult, relies on her biological memory, Otto, a patient with Alzheimer’s disease, must consult his notebook in order to retrieve the address of the Museum. Write a customer review. Intenvionalidad we shall see momentarily, this division is denied by the intentionalists. One can, however, believe and even know that there is a current flow between two points without believing, let alone knowing, that there is a voltage difference between the two points, if one fails to know that it is a law that if there is flow of electric current between two points, then there is inetncionalidad voltage difference between these two points see Jacob for discussion.
According to the first thesis, it is constitutive of the phenomenon of intentionality, as it is exhibited by mental states such brentaho loving, hating, desiring, believing, judging, perceiving, hoping and many others, that these mental states are directed towards things different from themselves.
If there was nothing it is like to believe that 5 is a prime number, then, according to the view that phenomenal consciousness is the criterion of the mental, many propositional attitudes would fail to qualify as genuine mental states. Credit offered by NewDay Ltd, over 18s only, subject to status. Intencionaljdad do they embrace Rorty’s irrealist attitude towards the mental.
The answer to this question is that human engineers designed these machines so that they would be sensitive to objects with a special kind of intrinsic physical properties because these objects generally if not always also happen to exemplify a special monetary value: